When designing entrances for offices, public buildings, or busy sites, you need to get the right balance of security, smooth user flow and aesthetics. Two common access control solutions are the traditional tripod turnstile and a modern single lane speed gate. Both options have their strengths and points to consider depending on the requirements of your site.
In this blog, we explore the advantages and things to consider for both solutions.
What is a tripod turnstile?
A tripod turnstile is a mechanical gate with three rotating arms, they are a popular solution for organisations seeking reliable access control that combines security and automation in a efficient package. Essentially, they work by when a user presents valid credentials such as a card, ticket, or key, the arms rotate to allow one person to pass. They are effective for sites that require controlled, one by one access.
Tripod turnstiles are often installed in public transport stations, gyms, stadiums, universities and other high traffic areas where access control is necessary. They are valued for their reliability and simplicity.
Let’s take a look at the advantages and things to consider when looking at tripod turnstiles.
Advantages of tripod turnstiles
- They are generally more cost effective than electronic gate systems.
- They are durable and designed to handle heavy foot traffic.
- Maintenance requirements are relatively low compared with more complex access control systems.
Considerations for tripod turnstiles
- Throughput is limited because only one person can pass per rotation, which can create queues during busy times.
- Accessibility can be challenging for wheelchair users or people carrying large items.
- Their industrial design may not suit modern office interiors or high-end commercial environments.
What is a single lane speed gate
For a more modern access control option, a single lane speed gate is a popular solution. Single lane speed gates use motorised barriers that are typically made of glass or stainless steel. When a user presents authorised credentials such as a card, mobile credential, or biometric scan, the barrier opens quickly to allow for smooth entry.
Single lane speed gates are designed for environments where both security and user experience are important. They are commonly used in corporate offices, airports, VIP lounges, and modern reception areas.
Here’s some of the to advantages and points to consider when looking at single lane speed gates:
Advantages of single lane speed gates
- High throughput with fast opening and closing cycles allow more people to pass through quickly compared with mechanical turnstiles.
- Advanced security with sensors help to detect tailgating or unauthorised access.
- Modern aesthetics with glass panels and sleek finishes fit contemporary building designs.
- Better accessibility with wider lanes make them suitable for wheelchair users, luggage or large items.
Considerations for single lane speed gates
- Initial investment is higher than for a tripod turnstile because of electronic and sensor components.
- Maintenance and power requirements may be greater, requiring specialist attention and support.
- Installation may need more space, especially for wider lanes or added safety features
Comparing tripod turnstiles and single lane speed gates
Choosing between a tripod turnstile and a single lane speed gate depends on several factors:
- Budget: Tripod turnstiles are generally more affordable initially, while single lane speed gates require a larger investment.
- Foot traffic volume: High traffic environments benefit from single lane speed gates because they allow faster flow.
- Security requirements: For basic entry control, tripod turnstiles are suitable. However, to reduce the risk of tailgating and benefit from real time monitoring or biometric integration, single lane speed gates would be the more ideal option.
- Accessibility: Single lane speed gates provide a more inclusive option for wheelchair users or people carrying large items.
- Design and image: Single lane speed gates provide a more modern and professional appearance, making them more suited for offices or high-end spaces.
For facilities that require a heavy use option, single lane speed gates are often the preferred choice. Whereas tripod turnstiles can be more sufficient for smaller sites with simpler security needs or tighter budgets.
Operational efficiency and security
Single lane speed gates offer advantages in both operational efficiency and security. Their sensors and automated barriers reduce the need for constant staff monitoring. They can detect unauthorised entries or attempts to follow someone through the gate, and alerts can be sent to security personnel immediately.
Tripod turnstiles are mechanically simpler and rely more on staff oversight to ensure security. They are reliable for counting and controlling individual entries but do not offer the same level of intelligent monitoring as a single lane speed gate.
Design and aesthetics
When it comes to appearance, tripod turnstiles tend to have an industrial appearance, which can feel utilitarian in corporate or modern environments. Single lane speed gates, by contrast, are designed to blend into contemporary interiors with glass and steel finishes, LED indicators, providing a more clean, professional appearance.
Also, many single lane speed gates can be customised to match the design and branding of a building, providing an aesthetically pleasing access control solution. They can also feature company logos or signage on glass panels, combining security with visual appeal.
Accessibility considerations
Accessibility is an important factor for any site. Tripod turnstiles often require users to navigate narrow rotating arms, which can be difficult for wheelchair users or those with mobility aids. Single lane speed gates can offer wide lane configurations that are fully compliant with accessibility standards. This ensures that all visitors can pass safely and comfortably without compromising on security.
Choosing the right solution
When selecting an access control system, it is essential to match the gate to your site’s needs. Tripod turnstiles remain effective for controlling entry at a lower cost and with minimal maintenance whereas single lane speed gates allow for higher throughput, enhanced security, better accessibility, and a more modern appearance.
Ultimately, the choice depends on the balance between budget, traffic, security requirements, accessibility, and your design preferences. In many cases, a combination of both types of access control may be suitable to meet specific needs across different areas of a building.
Final thoughts
Both tripod turnstiles and single lane speed gates provide reliable, proven access control.
At EA, we offer a full range of turnstiles and single lane speed gates for commercial, public and private facilities. Our team can help you choose the right access control system to suit your site, balancing security, flow, and aesthetics.
With the right system in place, you can provide secure and efficient access for employees, visitors and clients while enhancing the overall experience of your building entrance.
